Eucracy

What the EU actually controls, what it shares, and what it only nominally cannot touch.

What the EU actually controls

Exclusive competence, Art. 3 TFEU
EU control100%

Member states cannot legislate here. Full stop.

  • Customs union / tariffs
  • Competition rules for the internal market
  • Monetary policy (eurozone)
  • Conservation of marine biological resources (CFP)
  • Common commercial policy (all trade agreements)
  • Conclusion of international agreements that affect common rules

What the EU co-controls

Shared competence, Art. 4 TFEU
EU control80%

The EU legislates. Member states can legislate where the EU hasn't, but the EU has legislated so thoroughly in most of these areas that "where it hasn't" is a theoretical remnant.

  • Internal market (free movement of goods, services, capital, people)
  • Social policy (limited aspects)
  • Economic, social and territorial cohesion
  • Agriculture (CAP)
  • Environment
  • Consumer protection
  • Transport
  • Trans-European networks
  • Energy
  • Freedom, security and justice (asylum, immigration, borders, judicial cooperation)
  • Public health (protection aspects)

Reality check

"Shared" means "EU legislates first, you fill in the gaps." The gaps are mostly gone. What's left is implementation, which means writing national transposition laws that restate the directive in your language.

What the EU nominally can't touch

Supporting competence, Art. 6 TFEU
EU control70%

The EU can only "support, coordinate or supplement." No harmonisation. No legally binding acts that require alignment of national laws.

  • Protection and improvement of human health
  • Industry
  • Culture
  • Tourism
  • Education, vocational training, youth, sport
  • Civil protection
  • Administrative cooperation

Reality check

"Support" means funding conditional on compliance. Erasmus+ requires Bologna alignment to get the money. The MDR is technically "shared" (the public health protection aspect), not "supporting." The line between "supporting" and "shared" is drawn by the Commission, and it keeps moving toward "shared."

What the EU cannot do in paper

Outside the Treaties
EU control60%

Areas that remain somewhat national, with exceptions.

  • Write your criminal code (minimum sanctions for specific cross-border offences)
  • Set your income tax (VAT is a directive, but income and corporate tax rates are national, except the Pillar Two minimum)
  • Control your military (NATO does that; CSDP is a joke)
  • Set your language policy
  • Control your constitution
  • Set your voting age
  • Legislate on culture, tourism, sport, education (in theory)

The supremacy question

The actual power dynamic

CJEU

EU law is supreme over everything, including constitutions. Period.

C-448/23, Dec 2025: national courts must "disregard" their own constitutional court's ruling if it conflicts with EU law.

National constitutional courts

No.

Germany, Poland, Czechia, Romania, Denmark, Spain, France, Croatia, Slovakia: all have said some version of "our constitution is the final word."

Slovakia, Sept 2025: passed a constitutional amendment explicitly giving national law precedence over EU law on "national identity" matters. The Commission launched infringement proceedings.

In practice

In practice, EU law wins, because enforcement is one-directional. The Commission can fine you, the CJEU can rule against you, and Article 7 can suspend your voting rights. You cannot fine the Commission. You cannot overrule the CJEU. The "sovereignty" of a national constitutional court is only as strong as the political will to accept the fines.

The honest summary

The EU is not a state. It is not a confederation. It is a regulatory supranational body with exclusive competence over the economic sphere, shared competence over most of the rest, and a one-directional enforcement mechanism that makes "resistance" expensive but not impossible.